These awards are based on number of people who have ridden the ride. Not everyone who voted made it to Waldameer this year. That said, despite how good RF2 is, it's not the "end all, be all" of wood coasters. It's probably in my personal top ten out of the more than 100 woodies I've ridden, but there are so many GREAT rides out there, so it's not surprising RF2 didn't rank at the top in its first year. I'm sure it's ranking will go up once more people have ridden it, but I can't imagine it's not going to rank higher than Voyage. It pales in comparison.