Rich and I both did our part and voted El Toro WAY ahead of Voyage. Of course, Boulder Dash is way better than both of them.
I think you are a
little bias there Sue ;-)
Just six match ups shy is very good. I think it will take a few years for Toro to actually come out ahead of Voyage however. I think maintenance issues may eventually catch up with Voyage, it is just too big, too powerful. But the Holiday World lovers will keep it on top no matter how the ride performs.
All of this isn't to say that Voyage is not an excellent ride and deserving of such a position, it is, I just think over time it may not do so well while I think with El Toro's construction it will last a lot longer.
As for the rest of the list, it is a very interesting list. Not many surprises, but it is interesting how some coasters seem to jostle places every year, like Phoenix, which seems to bounce around. Amazing, and understandable, how Shivering Timbers has fallen out of favor. Too bad Cedar Fair hasn't a clue as to how to deal with wooden coasters, even Six Flags gets it right at times (Wild One gets better each year IMO).